[Public WebGL] Some WebGL draft feedback

Gregg Tavares [email protected]
Mon Jan 4 22:20:41 PST 2010

On Mon, Jan 4, 2010 at 9:21 PM, Mark Callow <[email protected]>wrote:

> Gregg Tavares wrote:
>> ... [snip] ...
>> I don't follow the logic here? Which OS doesn't allow someone to use any
>> API they want to draw to a window? Which system doesn't allow you to use any
>> code you want to draw to a rectangle of pixels? Maybe I'm reading something
>> into it but it seems like allowing multiple contexts as the normal thing to
>> do and not allowing multiple contexts is only being advocated because it's
>> hard for WebGL which doesn't seem like it should be the deciding factor.
>> Rather then limit the usefulness of canvas by making it not allowed to have
>> multiple contexts because of WebGL, if WebGL can't share then it doesn't
>> belong in canvas.
>> ... [snip] ...
> Sure you can use any API you want to draw to a window. If you start using
> multiple APIs for simultaneous drawing to the same window, which is what you
> are requesting here, it is entirely conceivable that the OS may not support
> it. When supported, at a minimum the application has to take responsibility
> for finding a suitable pixel format and synchronizing the drawing of those
> different APIs.

What I am proposing is that the the only meaningful definition of the canvas
tag is "a rectangle of pixels that allows multiple simultaneous APIs to
effect those pixels" because as I pointed out, without multiple simultaneous
contexts the canvas tag provides nothing that <object> or a specific
<canvas2d> tag would not have supplied.

Because any other definition of the canvas tag (ie, a single context) makes
the canvas tag meaningless, then it seems like there are 2 ways forward.

1) keep WebGL as part of the canvas, make it deal with multiple contexts on
the tag.

2) make WebGL its own tag so it doesn't have to deal with other contexts

I personally prefer #2 as it provides the opportunity to take the WebGL in
directions that are arguably incompatible with the canvas tag.

> Regards
>   -Mark
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://khronos.org/pipermail/public_webgl_khronos.org/attachments/20100104/009e2f70/attachment.html>

More information about the public_webgl mailing list